For offshore sailors, wilderness explorers, and emergency responders, a satellite phone (sat phone) is a literal lifeline. By bypassing terrestrial cell towers and connecting directly to orbiting satellites, these devices provide coverage where your iPhone or Android becomes a “brick.”
However, satellite technology is not a magic bullet. If you are considering investing in one, you must ask: What is the disadvantage of a satellite phone? From high operational costs to physical limitations, here is a detailed breakdown of the drawbacks you need to know before heading off-grid.
1. High Initial and Operational Costs
The most immediate barrier for most users is the price tag. Unlike smartphones, which are often subsidized by carriers, satellite phones require a significant upfront investment.
-
Hardware Costs: A basic sat phone like the Iridium 9555 usually starts around $700, while high-end models can exceed $1,500.
-
Service Plans: Monthly subscriptions are expensive, often costing $50 to $100 just to keep the line active, with very few (if any) minutes included.
-
Per-Minute Charges: Voice calls can cost anywhere from $1.00 to $5.00 per minute, making long conversations a luxury.
2. Line-of-Sight Requirements
A satellite phone is not a “use anywhere” device in the way a cell phone is. It requires a clear, unobstructed view of the sky.
-
Environmental Interference: Deep canyons, dense forest canopies, and even tall city buildings can block the signal. If you are indoors, the phone will generally not work unless you are standing by a window or using an external antenna.
-
Weather Sensitivity: While most networks are robust, extreme weather like heavy storm clouds or intense solar activity can degrade signal quality or cause dropped calls.
3. Significant Signal Latency
Because the signal must travel from your handset to a satellite in space (and then back down to a ground station), there is a noticeable delay in audio, known as latency.
-
The “Walkie-Talkie” Effect: In a conversation, you may experience a 1–2 second delay. This requires both parties to speak slowly and wait for a response to avoid “stepping on” each other's words.
-
Data Speeds: If you plan on using a sat phone for internet, be prepared for 1990s-era speeds. Most handheld sat phones offer data speeds of around 2.4 kbps—barely enough for text-based emails, let alone web browsing.
Comparison: Satellite Phone Disadvantages by Network
Not all satellite networks are created equal. The “disadvantage” can change depending on which satellite constellation the phone uses.
| Disadvantage Factor | Iridium (LEO) | Inmarsat (Geosynchronous) | Thuraya (Regional) |
| Signal Obstruction | Lower risk (moving satellites) | High risk (fixed position) | High risk (fixed position) |
| Latency (Delay) | Low (~0.5 seconds) | High (~1-2 seconds) | High (~1-2 seconds) |
| Coverage Gaps | None (Global) | Poor at North/South Poles | Limited to EMEA/Asia |
| Call Dropping | Can happen as sats pass | Rare if you have a lock | Rare if you have a lock |
| Device Portability | Bulky, external antennas | Slightly more modern | Most like a cell phone |
4. Bulkier Hardware and Short Battery Life
While smartphones have become slim and pocket-friendly, satellite phones have remained relatively bulky.
-
Large Antennas: Most sat phones require a large, extendable antenna that must be pointed toward the sky to maintain a connection.
-
Battery Drain: Searching for a satellite signal is energy-intensive. While standby time is generally good, the “talk time” on many satellite phones is significantly shorter than modern smartphones.
5. Complexity of Use
Using a satellite phone requires a learning curve. You cannot simply hit “call” and put the phone to your ear immediately.
-
You must extend the antenna.
-
You must wait for the device to “register” with the satellite (which can take 30 seconds to several minutes).
-
You must maintain your position to avoid losing the “handshake” between the device and the satellite.
Is a Satellite Phone Still Worth It?
Despite these disadvantages, the “pros” outweigh the “cons” if your life depends on it. If you are in the middle of the Pacific Ocean or the Sahara Desert, a high per-minute cost is a small price to pay for a rescue.
However, for casual hikers or those staying within 10–20 miles of civilization, a Satellite Messenger (like the Garmin inReach) might be a better alternative. These devices are cheaper, smaller, and focus on two-way texting rather than expensive voice calls.
